A joint report from environmental organisations in Germany, Poland, Spain and France, and financed by the German environment ministry, says direct connections between capitals such as Paris and Berlin could make a major contribution to reducing carbon emissions. The study notes that a flight from Paris to Berlin causes at least six times the CO2 emissions of a train journey. Daniel Boffey discusses latest developments in an article on the Guardian website.
Revival of Trans Europe Express ‘key to EU’s carbon neutrality’
The resurrection of a 1960s network of direct rail routes between major European capitals known as the Trans Europe Express is key to achieving carbon neutrality in the EU by 2050, according to a report funded by the German government.
Due in large part to the growth of short-haul flights, 149 of the 365 cross-border rail links that once existed in Europe were non-operational in 2018, with rail now accounting for only 8% of all passenger travel in EU member states.
The joint report from environmental organisations in Germany, Poland, Spain and France, and financed by the German environment ministry, says direct connections between capitals such as Paris and Berlin could make a major contribution to reducing carbon emissions.
The German transport minister, Andreas Scheuer, had tentatively suggested in September that the network of routes that flourished in the 1960s and 70s could be the model for a new set to connections from 2025.
The Trans Europe Express was a first-class-only service launched in 1957 that at its peak served more than 31 different routes, including direct connections between key European capitals.
Its luxury trains stopped running in 1995 as it lost out to short-haul flights and national governments’ desire to invest in domestic high-speed rail. After 2000, train operators also had to pay track access charges as they cross borders that were often prohibitively high.
The report from Germanwatch, Poland’s Civil Affairs Institute, France Nature Environment, the Eco-union in Spain and the pan-European NGO Transport & Environment, notes that a flight from Paris to Berlin causes at least six times the CO2 emissions of a train journey.
Intra-European flights on distances less than 1,000km (621 miles) are estimated to create 28 million metric tonnes of CO2 every year. Seventeen of the 20 most frequented air routes in Europe are for distances less than 700km (434 miles).
“In theory, almost all of these journeys could be shifted to rail,” the report says.
The paper claims Europe’s railways are not more than a patchwork of national systems. Most services stop at the border, or end just on the other side, forcing travellers to change trains several times to get from one capital to the other, it is said.
The report proposes direct rail connections between Warsaw-Vilnius, Warsaw-Prague, Berlin-Copenhagen, Berlin-Brussels, Berlin-Paris, Paris-Madrid and Madrid-Lisbon.
It is claimed that in many cases the current infrastructure would permit the new routes to become operable and that it is a matter of improving the coordination of timetables.
“What is needed is a European spirit in planning and management of rail services, and start-up support for new international services. In the 1960s and 70s, a network of direct transcontinental services connected Europe across borders – the Trans-Europe Express (TEE),” the report says.
“This joint endeavour of French, German, Swiss, Dutch, Belgian, Luxembourg and Italian railways only offered first-class services and only connected a number of countries in western and central Europe; however, the idea might serve as a starting point. TEE trains only stopped at major cities and were often scheduled to allow travellers to do a roundtrip in a single day.”
The report also says service providers should share more data and that one-stop-shops should be established to allow travellers to book tickets with the assurance they will not be liable for missed connections.