Explaining why electricity use is declining

Steven Nadel writes on the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE) website about his analysis to explain why electricity use is declining in the U.S. It would be good to see equivalent analysis for Europe or other regions.  Let us know.

 

U.S. Electricity Use is Declining and Energy Efficiency May be a Significant Factor

U.S. electricity sales peaked in 2007 and have been declining modestly since then. Sales in 2012 were 1.9% lower than 2007 sales, and sales in the first ten months of 2013 are below the same period in 2012. While the economic recession is an obvious explanation for the decline in sales in 2008 and 2009, it is much less clear why sales have continued to decline since then, even as the economy began to recover. While some observers have attributed this stalled growth to the ongoing effects of the “Great Recession,” other observers suggest other factors may have played a role, such as erosion of manufacturing, more efficient buildings, lighting and appliances and increased use of on-site generation.

ACEEE has just completed an analysis on electricity-use trends since 1993 and we looked at changes in sales over the 2007-2012 period in particular. We found that no single factor can explain the change in electricity use over the 1993-2012 period. The factors that appear most significant were energy efficiency programs and policies, warmer weather, changes in gross domestic product (GDP), changes in electricity prices, and long-term trends.

Over the more recent period of 2007-2012, savings resulting from energy efficiency programs and policies, and from warmer winter weather, appear to be the most important contributors to declining electricity use in the residential and commercial sectors. This finding is consistent with the ramp-up of energy efficiency savings achieved from utility-sector energy efficiency programs, and from appliance and equipment efficiency standards that have taken effect since 2007. The other possible factors that we considered, such as GDP and electricity prices, did not change very much over the last six years and therefore do not appear to have had a significant effect on the recent decline in electricity use. The factors contributing to the decline in electricity use in the industrial sector are less clear but may include energy efficiency programs and policies as well.

Contribution of Each Variable to Change in Residential and Commercial Sector Per Capita Electricity Use Between 2007 and 2012

c-figure9 Note: Asterisked variables are statistically significant with 90% confidence in our regression analysis.

Further analysis and more data are needed to better understand the relative contribution of energy efficiency to declining electricity sales. In particular, we need to further examine what is occurring in the industrial sector. That analysis may need to wait for better industrial data to emerge, and for underlying trends in this sector to further manifest themselves as the sector recovers from the “Great Recession.”

The factors influencing electricity use are complex and difficult to boil down to a few key explanatory factors. For a variety of reasons we explain in the full paper, our results should be considered indicative, not definitive. It will be useful to update the analysis in a few years to see if the recent decline in electricity use, and the contribution of energy efficiency to this decline, continue. For example, if the recent cold winter weather continues, electricity for heating could be higher in 2014. Even so, our analysis suggests that energy efficiency has become an important factor in the level of U.S. electricity consumption.

2 thoughts on “Explaining why electricity use is declining

  1. The US is not the only country where electricity sales are dropping. This has been happening too in much of Western Europe. Certainly it has been happening in both Germany and the UK. But look at how differently the two Governments are responding regarding projections of future demand for electricity. In 2050 Berlin reckons that Germany will be using 25 per cent less electricity than today. But the UK energy secretary Ed Davey still carries on planning on the presumption that over the next 35 years consumption of electricity in the UK will double! Is this in order to justify his plans for ten or more new nuclear power stations?

    1. I heard yesterday that Ed Davey was justifying nuclear in reducing dependence on imported natural gas. He never mentioned that much of the natural gas was used directly for heating homes. So, he wasn’t being totally honest in explaining things. But he will do anything to justify the new nuclear plants, no doubt. Andrew, thanks for your comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.